The latest developments in the please call me case have reached a critical turning point, with the Constitutional Court’s landmark ruling on July 31, 2025, setting the stage for a final showdown. This long-running legal battle between Nkosana Makate and Vodacom spans over two decades, capturing South Africa’s attention with its twists and turns.
Recent constitutional court decision
In a significant judgment delivered by Acting Deputy Chief Justice Mbuyiseli Madlanga, the Constitutional Court overturned the Supreme Court of Appeal’s (SCA) previous ruling that favoured Makate. The court criticised the SCA’s analysis of evidence, necessitating a fresh hearing with a new panel of judges.
The case will now proceed to the SCA on November 18, 2025, marking what many hope will be the final chapter in this prolonged legal saga.
Key developments and deadlines
- Vodacom must submit appeal documents by September 15, 2025
- New SCA hearing scheduled for November 18, 2025
- Previous R47 million compensation agreement under review
Historical context of the dispute
The please call me case originated from an agreement between Makate and Phillip Geissler, Vodacom’s former Director of Product Development. The 2016 Constitutional Court judgment confirmed this agreement’s validity and ordered negotiations for reasonable compensation.
Legal framework and implications
The case has evolved from a simple contractual dispute into a complex legal matter involving intellectual property rights. It highlights the importance of proper documentation and fair compensation for innovative ideas in the telecommunications sector.
Financial implications
The compensation amount remains a central point of contention. The previous R47 million figure, which was set aside, demonstrates the significant financial stakes involved in this landmark case.
Looking ahead
The latest developments in the please call me case suggest that resolution may finally be within reach. With new deadlines set and fresh perspectives from the SCA pending, both parties await what could be the definitive ruling in this historic legal battle.
