Tag: insubordination

The concept of insubordination means ‘refusal to obey a lawful and reasonable instruction’. Gross insubordination can be a ground for dismissal. However, the employer has the onus of proving that the act was, in fact, one of insubordination and that it was gross (very serious). An employer’s belief that insubordination has occurred can easily trigger an emotional response from the executive who issued the instruction.

Employers and managers have the prerogative to set workplace rules and standards, including performance standards. Oftentimes, managers come across as being harsh, bullish, dismissive, or overly critical when attempting to enforce certain workplace standards.

The Labour Appeal Court recently issued an order refusing to grant leave to appeal against the judgment of the Labour Court, after the Labour Court reinstated an employee who was dismissed for voicing her dissatisfaction with the company’s policy on wearing high-heeled shoes on mine premises.

With the daily COVID-19 infection rate in South Africa increasing rapidly, many employees are having second thoughts on whether they should be returning to an office environment. This may occur when circumstances may arise where refusing to work is believed to be the only safe option available.

Issue - Whether an employee who makes a false allegation of racism against another employee can be dismissed?