South Africa is increasingly attracting people who are choosing to relocate, return or spend a greater portion of the year in the country. Whether drawn by its lifestyle, favourable climate, investment opportunities or relatively low cost of living, more individuals with international assets and financial interests are establishing tax residency in South Africa. While relocating to South Africa offers many benefits, it can also have significant tax implications.
South African tax residence does not depend solely on citizenship, immigration status or the purchase of immovable property. Under domestic law, a person becomes a South African tax resident if they are either “ordinarily resident” in South Africa or spend enough time in the country to meet the physical presence test. However, a double tax agreement may treat them as a tax resident of another country.
How South African tax residency is determined
In broad terms, a person is ordinarily resident in South Africa if the country represents their real or settled home. It must also be the place to which they would naturally return after temporary periods of absence. A person who is not ordinarily resident may still become tax resident under the physical presence test. This happens if they spend sufficient time in South Africa over a five-year period.
A person can become “ordinarily resident” in South Africa from their date of arrival. This applies when sufficient ties indicate that they intend to make South Africa their “new home”. Only when this position remains inconclusive, such as when they retain strong ties in another jurisdiction, does the physical presence test become relevant.
In either case, the provisions of a tax treaty should be considered. These determine whether another country regards the person as a treaty resident. If so, treaty residence takes precedence. Consequently, the person will not become tax resident in South Africa, even if they meet one of the domestic tests.
Tax liability
From the date a person becomes a South African tax resident, they become liable for tax on their worldwide assets and income. The tax authorities assign a market value to their worldwide assets on that date. This ensures that only future gains become subject to tax. Therefore, only the growth in asset values after establishing tax residence attracts South African tax. It is consequently important to have all assets valued when relocating to South Africa and establishing tax residency.
Conversely, when South African tax residence ceases, residents are deemed to dispose of their worldwide assets at market value. This valuation takes place at the time their tax residence ends. The deemed disposal attracts an exit tax on the appreciation of their worldwide assets. Unless the destination jurisdiction allows a similar adjustment to the tax base, another jurisdiction may tax the same amount again when the individual eventually disposes of those assets.
The tax implications of relocating to South Africa can also extend to foreign companies, trusts, foundations and other structures in which new residents hold interests. Any involvement in managing foreign entities from South Africa may bring those entities into the South African tax net.
Relocating to South Africa also creates opportunities to plan foreign asset holdings before arrival. With proper planning, individuals can establish and fund foreign structures before their South African tax residence commences. These structures can provide a tax-efficient investment approach.
South African tax residents are, in principle, taxed on their worldwide income and capital gains. However, applicable tax treaties may provide relief. Tax rebates for foreign taxes paid may also apply. This means individuals should consider the South African tax implications of foreign-source income, pension payouts, trust distributions and gains on foreign investments.
Foreign investment income streams
Without attempting to provide a comprehensive overview, we discuss a few typical foreign investment income streams. These relate to foreigners moving to South Africa and former South Africans returning to the country.
-
Foreign pensions
Under many of South Africa’s tax treaties, South Africa receives exclusive taxing rights over pension payments made to South African tax residents. However, South Africa exempts foreign pensions derived from past employment outside the country. In these circumstances, the tax benefits of retiring in South Africa become evident. Therefore, individuals considering relocating to South Africa should assess the treatment of their foreign pension arrangements before making the move.
-
Foreign dividends
Generally, South Africa levies tax on foreign dividends at a maximum rate of 20%. However, taxpayers can claim credits for foreign taxes paid on these dividends. Tax treaties may also limit the foreign tax that another country can levy. This, in turn, affects the amount taxpayers can claim as a credit in South Africa.
Foreign dividends from equity interests of 10% or more are likely to qualify for the participation exemption on foreign dividends.
-
Foreign interest
South Africa taxes foreign interest earned by residents at the maximum applicable income tax rates. However, taxpayers may claim credits for foreign taxes levied on this interest.
-
Foreign capital gains
South African tax residents who are natural persons face capital gains tax at a maximum rate of 18%. This applies to capital gains derived from disposing of their worldwide assets. However, taxpayers may claim credits for foreign taxes payable.
Taxpayers determine these gains using the stepped-up tax base established when they become South African tax residents, as explained above.
The disposal of substantial foreign equity interests can also qualify for the foreign capital gains participation exemption. This applies to interests of 10% or more that individuals have held for at least 18 months. In such cases, they will not pay South African tax on the qualifying gains.
-
Foreign rental income
Generally, tax treaties allocate primary taxing rights to the country where the rental-earning property is situated. However, South Africa also taxes this income and provides a credit for foreign taxes paid.
In countries with generous tax thresholds for rental income, the South African tax liability often exceeds the foreign tax payable on that income.
-
Foreign funding from discretionary family structures
South Africa has complex rules governing the taxation of awards to South African beneficiaries of foreign family structures. To determine the tax treatment, individuals must undertake a South African exercise. This involves categorising the retained funds within the structure according to South African tax principles.
They must allocate awards to a specific category of these retained funds. Although this categorisation process can be onerous, the outcome often allows South African tax resident beneficiaries to receive tax-efficient funding from foreign structures.
Planning before arrival in the country
Planning before arrival in South Africa is often critical to achieving tax efficiency in this regard. Therefore, individuals relocating to South Africa should consider these arrangements well before establishing tax residence.
The tax implications of becoming a South African tax resident are manageable. In certain circumstances, they can also create opportunities for tax efficiency. However, individuals should consider these implications early.
Proactive advice can help avoid unexpected tax leakage, preserve flexibility and ensure that offshore wealth structures remain appropriate once South African tax residence becomes relevant.
| Doelie Lessing | Director | Head of Private Wealth | mail me | | Luke Magerman | Senior Associate | mail me | | Mike Searle | Candidate Attorney | mail me | |
| | Werksmans Attorneys | | ||
