Dr Oluwaseun Adeoye Oyebamiji | Development Economist | Associate | Free Market Foundation | mail me |
Nigeria’s public-sector unions want petrol at ₦500 a litre or a minimum wage of ₦500,000. Both demands respond to real hardship. However, both would make it worse.
In September, the trade union side of the Joint National Public Service Negotiating Council wrote to President Bola Tinubu. It requested a reduction in petrol prices to ₦500 a litre. It also demanded an immediate wage award for workers across all three tiers of government.
Furthermore, it sought a new minimum wage of at least ₦500,000 a month for the lowest grade from 2027 (Yusuf, 2026). The council set the pump price at ₦1,430 a litre or more. Meanwhile, the current national minimum wage stands at ₦70,000 a month (National Minimum Wage (Amendment) Act, 2024). Unions have since staged a three-day warning strike and threatened a longer one.
The pressure behind the letter is real. Petrol now costs about seven times the controlled price of under ₦200 a litre that applied before the government removed the subsidy in 2023. Food prices also remain high. Meanwhile, a minimum wage set in 2024 has lost much of its value. However, the two proposed remedies would repeat mistakes Nigeria has only recently stopped making. Any debate about Nigeria’s petrol subsidy must therefore consider both the immediate cost-of-living crisis and the longer-term economic consequences of government intervention.
The cost of restoring Nigeria’s petrol subsidy
In mid-September, Brent crude traded above $100 a barrel. At the same time, the Dangote refinery’s gantry price stood at ₦1,350 a litre (Oparada, 2026). A pump price of ₦500 would amount to little more than a third of that wholesale price.
This calculation excludes transport costs and retail margins. Someone would have to pay the difference. Under the old regime, the Federation covered that cost through NNPC.
Drawing on official figures, Al Jazeera estimated that Nigeria spent about ₦11.7 trillion on the subsidy between 2016 and 2023 (Adetayo, 2023). Much of the cheap petrol was reportedly smuggled into neighbouring countries. If the government refuses to cover the difference, a price cap would produce shortages. Nigerians remember the queues.
In 1945, Friedrich Hayek explained why. A price acts as a signal. High petrol prices tell consumers to economise and encourage producers and importers to supply more. Fixing prices below cost blocks both signals. Similarly, Ayittey (2006) described indigenous African markets where buyers and sellers settled prices through bargaining rather than accepting decrees from rulers.
Why a higher minimum wage could exclude workers
The wage demand raises a different problem. The National Bureau of Statistics estimates that about 93% of Nigerian employment is informal. It also estimates that around 85.6% of working people are self-employed (Tunji, 2024).
Although these measures differ, both show how few Nigerians work for wages in registered firms. In practice, a minimum wage covers only a small formal minority, including civil servants and employees of registered firms. Raising it more than sevenfold would not reach traders, farmers or artisans. Instead, it would increase the cost of every formal job.
Nigerian evidence on how employers would respond to an increase of this size remains limited. Nevertheless, likely outcomes include fewer formal jobs, more contract and informal hiring, and greater pressure on state wage bills.
South Africa offers a useful comparison. Despite very high unemployment, we have proposed a Job Seekers Exemption Certificate. This certificate would allow unemployed people to opt out of minimum wage rules and bargaining-council agreements. They could then negotiate directly with employers.
Our spokesman argued that regulation has “priced [the] unemployed out of the labour market” (Le Roux, 2026). The proposal remains untested. However, it recognises that a high legal minimum can exclude people outside the formal economy rather than protect them.
Addressing workers’ hardship without distorting prices
There is a reasonable argument on the other side. Public servants are not responsible for inflation. Moreover, governments that print money or devalue their currencies transfer real income away from salaried workers. Wage reviews should therefore take place regularly.
Governments that employ people should also pay their staff on time. However, a reasonable wage review is not a sevenfold increase. Similarly, demanding a fixed petrol price effectively calls for the return of a subsidy that drained the Federation’s revenue for years. Nigeria’s petrol subsidy debate must distinguish between legitimate demands for income protection and policies that create further economic distortions.
Instead, policymakers should focus on the factors driving up living costs. Food prices reflect insecurity, input costs, and trade restrictions. Transport costs reflect poor roads and a network of official and unofficial levies imposed on vehicles. Credit remains scarce because the central bank holds almost half of every deposit. Each of these factors reflects a policy choice. Policymakers can change them without introducing a subsidy or imposing a wage decree.
Labour leaders could press for precisely these reforms. They could demand lower taxes on goods that workers buy, an end to checkpoint extortion and more open food trade. They could also call for a public service that pays workers on time and promotes them on merit.
Such a programme would increase the real value of every naira earned. It would also address the structural problems behind the cost-of-living crisis rather than rely on short-term price controls. In this respect, reforming the conditions that shape Nigeria’s petrol subsidy debate could deliver more lasting benefits than restoring the subsidy itself.
Nigeria spent decades fixing petrol prices and paid for it through debt, smuggling and shortages. It would be a pity to return to that path just as the country has begun to leave it.
Sources
Adetayo, O. (2023, May 31). Nigeria fuel subsidy cut and spiralling costs: What to know. Al Jazeera. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/5/31/nigeria-fuel-subsidy-cut-spiralling-costs-all-you-need-to-know.
Ayittey, G. B. N. (2006). Indigenous African institutions (2nd ed.). Transnational Publishers.
Hayek, F. A. (1945). The use of knowledge in society. The American Economic Review, 35(4), 519–530.
Le Roux, K. (2026, April 16). New plan could let unemployed South Africans bypass labour laws. Eyewitness News. https://ewn.co.za/2026/04/16/new-plan-could-let-unemployed-south-africans-bypass-labour-laws.
National Minimum Wage (Amendment) Act, 2024 (Nigeria).
Oparada, P. (2026, September 13). Filling stations release new petrol prices as Dangote raises rate to N1,350. Legit.ng. https://www.legit.ng/business-economy/energy/1730478-filling-stations-release-petrol-prices-dangote-raises-rate-n1350/.
Tunji, T. (2024, November 26). NBS says 85.6% of working-class Nigerians are self-employed. Nairametrics. https://nairametrics.com/2024/11/26/nbs-says-85-6-of-working-class-nigerians-are-self-employed/.
Yusuf, R. A. (2026, September 21). Civil servants demand N500 petrol price, wage award from Tinubu. Legit.ng. https://www.legit.ng/nigeria/1732078-civil-servants-demand-n500-petrol-price-wage-award-tinubu/.
